Where to Find Great Pizza in the Brighton Howell Area, According to Locals

When it comes to pizza, everyone has an opinion.

We recently asked the community where to find their favorite pizza around the Brighton Howell Area, and the recommendations came rolling in. From specialty pies and classic favorites to creative topping combinations, local pizza fans had plenty of places to share.

So, whether you're planning a casual dinner, picking up pizza for family night, or looking for a new local favorite, here are some of the spots that earned a shoutout from the community.

See the original post

A Local Favorite: Captain’s on Main

If there was one name that kept popping up in the conversation, it was Captain’s on Main.

Locals repeatedly recommended this Brighton favorite, known for its wood-fired pizzas and creative specialty combinations. If you're looking for a pizza spot with a strong local following, start here.

Brighton

Make It a Pizza and Wine Night at Howell MainStreet Winery & Pizzeria

Pizza and wine make a pretty great combination, and Howell MainStreet Winery & Pizzeria received several local shoutouts.

One specialty that caught attention was the Big Sexy Pizza #3. With stone-oven, thin-crust pizza and a downtown Howell setting, it's a fun option for a relaxed night out.

Howell

Find Your Favorite Style at Coratti’s Pizzeria Bar and Bocce

Can't agree on a pizza style? Coratti’s has something for different kinds of pizza fans.

Locals recommend both its Neapolitan-style and Detroit-style pizzas. Add in a game of bocce, and you've got another reason to make this Howell spot part of your next night out.

Howell

Try Something Different at Hartland Brewing Co.

If you like getting creative with your toppings, Hartland Brewing Co. deserves a spot on your list.

Locals recommended BBQ chicken, Greek chicken, and dill pickle pizza. If you've never tried pickle pizza, consider this your sign to branch out beyond the usual toppings!

Hartland

Make a Pinckney Stop at Riverside Pizza

Exploring around Pinckney? Riverside Pizza is a longtime local option near the Huron River.

It's a great name to keep in mind when you're looking for a casual pizza stop during your next Brighton Howell Area adventure.

Pinckney

Pair Pizza With Lake Time at Zukey Lake Tavern

Planning a day around the Pinckney area? Consider adding Zukey Lake Tavern to your itinerary.

Its pizza options include specialty and build-your-own pies, making it another spot to keep in mind when you're craving pizza near the lake.

Pinckney

Your Next Favorite Pizza Spot Is Waiting

From wood-fired specialty pies in Brighton to creative topping combinations in Hartland and classic local favorites in Pinckney, the Brighton Howell Area has plenty of options when a pizza craving hits.

The best part? There are always more local spots to discover. Whether you're planning a family pizza night, meeting friends for dinner, or grabbing a bite while exploring a nearby downtown, make a stop at one of these community favorites and find your new go-to order.

Have a local pizza favorite we missed? Keep the recommendations coming! Your next suggestion could help someone else discover their new favorite slice.

Ready to keep exploring? Check out more local restaurants, breweries, wineries, and hidden gems throughout the Brighton Howell Area.

Discover more Food & Drink